What If You Sell Company Stock and It Keeps Climbing?
It might. You can be wrong by selling or wrong by holding, and the two mistakes don’t cost the same.

I play blackjack every once in a while, usually on vacation. I’m not a big gambler. To me it’s entertainment, like going to a show, and I’m fine if the night costs me a few hundred dollars. But I noticed something at those tables. If I won a couple thousand dollars, it was cool, but I wasn’t ecstatic. If I lost a decent amount, it really got to me.
Your company stock can work on you the same way. When it climbs, you’re not that excited. It starts to feel like what’s supposed to happen. When it falls, that’s when the pain shows up.
But the question I hear from clients almost every day is about the climb. What if I sell some and it keeps climbing? That’s fear of missing out, and it’s real. I’ve been hearing some version of it for well over ten years.
If you have a lot of your money in your company’s stock, you’ve probably asked it too. You think about selling some. Then you imagine the price climbing for another year, and somebody at work who hasn’t sold a share telling you what theirs is worth now. So the stock stays right where it is.
When the stock is climbing, selling feels like getting off too early, and when it’s falling, it feels like quitting right before it comes back. If you’re waiting for the day selling feels right, that day may not come.
I can’t tell you whether it will keep climbing. Nobody can. So I don’t try to answer the question about the stock. I ask about you, because the same stock can be fine for one person to hold and too much for the person at the next desk.
Picture two people at the same company with the same number of shares. One has a house that’s paid for, no kids at home and twenty working years ahead. The other has two kids about to start college, a parent who is going to need help and five years until they want to stop working. If the stock falls by half, the first one may have a bad year. The second one may be working a lot longer than they planned.
I want to know which one you’re closer to. I want to know how many working years you have left and who is counting on this money. It even matters how you sleep, because some people can watch a stock fall by a third and be fine, and some can’t.
It’s the same reason what your coworkers are doing can’t tell you much. Neither can someone in your family, or what you heard on the news this morning. The person down the hall who is holding every share may be the first of those two people, and you may be the second. You can’t see their life from where you sit, and their answer was never going to be yours.
There are two ways to be wrong here. You can sell some and watch it keep climbing. That one stings, because you missed the rest of the climb on the shares you sold and you may owe tax on the sale. But the shares you kept climbed too, and if more of your stock is still vesting, more shares may be on the way.
Or you can hold all of it and watch it fall. That one can be harder to come back from. A stock that falls by half has to double just to get back to where it was, and one that falls 70 percent has to more than triple.
How often does a stock fall that far and stay down? Nobody knows for your company, but for companies in general, somebody counted. In 2014, J.P. Morgan published a study of about 13,000 U.S. stocks going back to 1980. About 40 percent of them had fallen 70 percent or more from their high and hadn’t made most of it back. Among technology companies it was 57 percent, and in biotech it was more than half.
About 7 percent of all those stocks were what the study called extreme winners, the ones that beat the market by a wide margin. The run you’re afraid of missing does happen. In that study, the big fall happened to far more companies. None of that tells you what your company will do.
A fall also tends to hurt more than a climb feels good. In 1979 two psychologists, Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, published a paper on how people weigh gains and losses. They wrote that losing a sum of money appears to bother people more than gaining the same amount pleases them. That’s what I noticed at the blackjack table.
Which of those two mistakes could your life take? If that stock is money you can live without, you can afford to hold it and be wrong. Holding can be the right call. If it’s tuition, or the year you stop working, or what you’d need if your parents needed you, then you can’t, and missing part of a run may be the cheaper mistake.
And selling some doesn’t have to take you out of the market. If you put that money back to work, it can be spread across hundreds of companies instead of one, and it can keep growing there. It can fall too. Even spread out, it can be down 10, 20 or 30 percent at times, and now and then more, because that’s what markets do. It just wouldn’t all be riding on one company anymore.
Many of the people I work with are executives, and some of them can only sell at certain times. So we plan it ahead and sell on a schedule. Once it’s set, it doesn’t take a new decision each time. The money gets spread out, so they stay invested, and they keep adding more every month or every quarter. When one stock gets way out of proportion to everything else, we trim some and put it to work somewhere else.
You don’t have to decide it all on one day either. You can sell in pieces over months or years, as long as your company’s trading rules and the law allow it. Once you’ve started, if the stock keeps climbing, the next piece sells for more, and if it falls, you sold some before it did. You probably won’t hit the top, and you don’t have to.
If you sell some and it keeps climbing, you made the mistake you decided you could afford, and you still own the rest.
Talk Tuesday.
Mateo
P.S. If a coworker is holding because they’re afraid of selling too early, send them this letter.
Not ready to talk? Get the next letter by email.
You’ll get the letters by email. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy
BFA Wealth Management isn’t affiliated with J.P. Morgan.