You’d Sell Some Company Stock If It Weren’t for the Taxes
The tax on stock that has grown for years is real. It’s also a number you can work out today, and waiting doesn’t always make it smaller.

At 21 I sat in the back of a lecture hall doing math under my desk instead of taking notes. I owned one stock, it had jumped that afternoon, and I figured the gain from that one afternoon was more than my professor made in years.
If I had sold, I would have owed tax on that gain. The bill never came. I held, the stock lost more than 99 percent of its value, and the gain went with it.
That’s one way a tax bill goes away. It is not a plan.
I think about it when I hear someone say they’d sell some of their company stock if it weren’t for the taxes. Maybe you’ve said it yourself.
It’s a fair thing to say. The stock may have come from years of RSUs, an ESPP, options, or a company you left a long time ago. I call that a legacy position. It has grown, so selling means a tax bill, and that bill is a number you can see today. What holding could cost you is a number you can’t see until later. So the tax wins the argument, and the stock sits another year.
Start with what the bill is. The tax applies to the gain, and your cost comes off first. With RSUs, your cost is what the shares were worth the day they were delivered to you, usually the day they vested, because that value was already taxed as pay.
That cost doesn’t always make it onto the form your broker sends the IRS. When it’s left out, it has to be added back on your tax return, or the same dollars can get taxed twice. Shares from incentive stock options and an ESPP follow rules of their own, with longer holding periods, and part of the gain on them can be taxed like pay.
On RSU shares you’ve held more than a year, the federal rate in 2026 is generally 0, 15 or 20 percent of the gain, depending on your taxable income. Higher earners also pay a 3.8 percent tax on investment income. State tax, where your state taxes investment gains, comes on top.
So the top federal rate comes to 23.8 percent of the gain. Even if every dollar of a sale were gain, that’s under a quarter of it. It’s real money. You can also work it out before you sell a single share. Unlike a vest, a sale usually has nothing withheld, so a big gain can mean you owe the IRS an estimated tax payment during the year, before you file your return.
Waiting does help sometimes, when you’re waiting for something specific. Gain on shares you’ve held a year or less is taxed at the same income tax rates as your pay, so getting past the one year mark can lower the rate. A year when your income drops can put the same gain in a lower bracket. Selling across two or three tax years instead of one can keep more of the gain out of the top rate.
Beyond that, more time generally doesn’t lower the rate. RSU shares in year two and year ten are generally taxed the same way. If the stock keeps climbing, the gain grows and the bill grows with it. And the rates can move. Congress has raised them and cut them before, and nobody knows where they’ll be the year you finally sell.
The bill does shrink if the stock falls. That’s how mine went away at 21. At the top rate, every dollar of gain you lose on RSU shares you’ve held more than a year saves you about 24 cents of federal tax. You’re still out the other 76.
The bill can also go away if you never sell. Under the law as it stands in 2026, the shares you still own when you die generally go to your heirs with their cost reset to that day’s value. The gain that built up while you owned them drops out of federal income tax. That can be a fine plan for money you’ll never need. It’s a poor one for money you’re counting on.
A few choices can lower the bill. Start with which shares you sell, because each batch has its own cost. In a stock that has climbed for years, the shares that vested last year usually carry far less gain than the ones from eight years ago. If you don’t tell your broker which shares to sell, the tax rules generally treat the oldest ones as sold first. Losses you’ve taken somewhere else can offset the gain. And if you already give to charity, you can give RSU shares you’ve held more than a year in place of cash. That can mean no tax on the gain in those shares and, if you don’t take the standard deduction, a deduction for their value, within limits.
None of this is a reason to sell. Holding can be the right call, and a stock you sold can keep climbing without you. I just don’t want the tax making the decision for you. If we were looking at your shares together, I’d want your CPA’s number on the table first, right next to what the money is for and what a few bad years in one stock would do to it. Sometimes the tax still wins. Then it’s a decision you made on purpose, and that’s a very different thing from a legacy position that sits because nobody added up the bill.
I never got a tax bill at 21, and I would have been glad to pay one, because it would have meant the gain was still there. I’d rather you make that call with the number in front of you than find out the way I did.
Talk Friday.
Mateo
P.S. If a coworker keeps saying they’d sell if it weren’t for the taxes, send them this letter.
Not ready to talk? Get the next letter by email.
You’ll get the letters by email. Unsubscribe any time. Privacy Policy